Back in the early 60's if you were walking down Court Street in down town Brooklyn with a Hero in your hand with peppers and onions hanging out of it, you can bet your last dollar you got it at Chubby Mary's.

In 1961 down on Court Street in the Red Hook Section of Brooklyn now called Carroll Gardens, our Grandfather, Dominick Casale and his son our Uncle Tommy Casale opened up a Hero Shop called Chubby Mary's. They served the same food that they would put on their own kitchen table at home. They believed in the power of peppers and onions.

Now over 50 years later, we are bringing that same tradition back to the East Village. Hot home-spun Italian American Heroes made to order with the same love and care our Grandfather and Uncle put into every hero they served.

Our mission is to get those peppers back on the streets of New York and we wont stop until the new generation understands what peppers and onions can do.

Hot Heros

Meatballs Provolone and gravy $10.00
Meatballs Onions and peppers $10.00
Veal Cutlet Broccoli rabe and provolone $10.00
Veal Cutlet Peppers, onions and provolone $10.00
Veal Cutlet Vodka sauce and provolone $10.00
Connies Hero Veal cutlet, buttered Italian bread and sliced tomatoes $10.00
Franks Hero Veal cutlet, tomatoes, olive oil, salt, pepper and oregano $10.00
Chicken Cutlet Peppers, onions and provolone $10.00
Chicken Cutlet Broccoli rabe and provolone $10.00
Chicken Cutlet Provolone and gravy $10.00
Chicken Cutlet Lettuce, tomato, mayo and provolone $10.00
Chicken Cutlet Vodka sauce and provolone $10.00
Sausage Broccoli rabe and provolone $10.00
Sausage Peppers, onions and provolone $10.00
Eggplant Provolone and Gravy $10.00
Eggplant Provolone $10.00
Shrimp Provolone and gravy $10.00
Shrimp Vodka sauce and provolone $10.00
2 Meat Balls In A Cup Provolone and gravy $5.00
Broccoli Rave In A Cup   $5.00
Stuffed Artichoke   $6.00

Cold Heros

Mortadella Vodka sauce $10.00
Soppresata Provolone and eggplant $10.00
Ham Boar's Head American Cheese $10.00
Turkey Boar's Head American Cheese $10.00
Mean Streets Prosciutto, ham, salami, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella and provolone $10.00
Tuna Olive oil, red onion, tomato, salt and pepper $10.00
Forgotten Fish Portuguese, sardines, sliced tomato, white onions, oil, vinegar, salt, pepper, mustard and mayo $10.00


Bella's Nice Salad Iceberg, onions, tomato, olives, salt, pepper, oil and vinegar $10.00
Joy's Nice Salad Meatball, iceberg, onions, tomatoes, olives, salt, pepper, oil and vinegar $10.00
Tomato Chicken Salad Chopped chicken cutlet, tomato, onion, olives, grated cheese, balsamic vinegar and roll $10.00

Breakfast Heros

Ham And Eggs Ham, eggs, American cheese and peppers $10.00
Eggs Peppers, onions and provolone $10.00
Eggs Pizzlole Served over-easy, tomato gravy, peccorino and provolone $10.00
Buttered Bread Peccorino and tomato gravy (Very Nice) $10.00
Bologna Eggs American cheese and buttered bread $10.00
Mortadella Eggs and provolone on buttered bread $10.00
Soppresata Onions, eggs, provolone $10.00


Brooklyn's Famous Black & White Cookie $4.00

Phone: (212) 228-2807

Address: 328 East 14th Street
(between First and Second Avenues)

Hours: 11am-11pm 7 days a week


Follow Us On:

View Larger Map